CRTW 201 PHF Chapter 10 Handout

Writing in class (5 minutes):  Identity the following elements in Chapter 10 (you should already have them marked in your margins):

1. Q@I:

2. Purpose:

3. Conclusion (find and quote a phrase, sentence, or passage that sums it up):

Group work (10 minutes):  Each group starts with a different element. 

4. What points of view does F mention on 183 and 187?

5. List concepts (you should have marked them in your book; there are at least 6):

6. List alternatives:

7. List consequences of regulation (183-84) and of the liberal view (192)

Handout on assumptions:  Work in groups to fill this out.

8. Identify false assumptions, especially on the following pages 184, 185, 187, and 188.

9. What true assumptions does F assert in opposition to the false ones in #8?

Information: 

• Restraining good/true science reflects badly upon regulation:  Galileo.
• Allowing corrupt science reflects badly upon lack of regulation:  Nazi doctors.
• These are the extremes.  What is F's own view?